Current:Home > ScamsNew York temporarily barred from taking action against groups for promoting abortion pill ‘reversal’ -ValueCore
New York temporarily barred from taking action against groups for promoting abortion pill ‘reversal’
View
Date:2025-04-18 08:57:53
Citing free speech rights, a federal judge has temporarily blocked New York’s attorney general from taking enforcement action against certain pregnancy counseling centers for promoting what critics say is an unproven method to reverse medication abortions.
U.S. District Judge John Sinatra Jr. in Buffalo issued a preliminary injunction against state Attorney General Letitia James and her office on Thursday. The order says James’ office cannot take legal action against two centers and a related association while their lawsuit against James is pending in federal court.
The lawsuit accuses James of unfairly targeting anti-abortion groups because of their viewpoints, including their promotion of a protocol called the “Abortion Pill Reversal.” It cites a lawsuit James’ office filed in state court in May against another anti-abortion group and nearly a dozen other pregnancy counseling centers for promoting abortion medication reversals.
James’ case against the other groups follows a similar lawsuit in California and other legal action in states such as Colorado regarding unsubstantiated treatments to reverse medication abortions.
Medication abortion, the most common way to end a pregnancy, involves taking two different drugs — mifepristone and misoprostol — days apart.
James’ office says the anti-abortion groups are advising people who have taken mifepristone not to take the follow-up of misoprostol and instead receive repeated doses of the hormone progesterone.
James’ office says the treatment has not been approved by federal regulators, and major medical associations have warned that the protocol is unproven and unscientific.
Sinatra, nominated to the court in 2019 by then-President Donald Trump, a Republican, wrote in his decision that the First Amendment protects free speech, even when that speech contains false statements. He also said the two pregnancy counseling centers and related association are likely to prevail in their lawsuit against James.
The centers have a First Amendment right to “speak freely” about the reversal protocol and say it is safe and effective to use in consultation with a doctor, the judge said.
“Plaintiffs are irreparably harmed each day that their First Amendment freedoms are infringed,” Sinatra wrote.
He added the preliminary injunction “serves the public interest by allowing women to access and receive information that may lead to saving the lives of their unborn children.”
James’ office had opposed the preliminary injunction, calling it in court documents “a collateral attack” on the office’s pending lawsuit against the other pregnancy counseling centers. Her office also said it has authority to “enforce state protections against consumer fraud and false advertising.”
James’ office had no immediate comment on the injunction Friday.
The plaintiffs that sought the injunction include the National Institute for Family and Life Advocates and two of its member centers — Gianna’s House in Brewster north of New York City and Options Care Center in Jamestown in western New York. The Virginia-based anti-abortion group has member pregnancy counseling centers across the country, including 51 in New York.
The preliminary injunction only applies to those plaintiffs, and not the centers named in James’ lawsuit in state court.
Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative group representing the plaintiffs in court, hailed the judge’s ruling.
“Women in New York have literally saved their babies from an in-progress chemical drug abortion because they had access to information through their local pregnancy centers about using safe and effective progesterone for abortion pill reversal,” Caleb Dalton, the group’s senior counsel, said in a statement. “But the attorney general tried to deny women the opportunity to even hear about this life-saving option.”
In court documents, James’ office said there is no valid evidence that abortion pill reversal is safe or effective in increasing the chances of pregnancy, and that the use of progesterone in the process has never been approved by the Food and Drug Administration.
veryGood! (2298)
Related
- Most popular books of the week: See what topped USA TODAY's bestselling books list
- US Postal Service is abandoning a plan to reroute Reno-area mail processing to Sacramento
- Body of Utah man who fell from houseboat recovered from Lake Powell
- Channing Tatum Reveals Jaw-Dropping Way He Avoided Doing Laundry for a Year
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- Lawsuit filed over Arkansas Republican officials blocking effort to close state GOP primary
- Opening day of Burning Man marred by woman's death, harsh weather conditions
- US appeals court revives a lawsuit against TikTok over 10-year-old’s ‘blackout challenge’ death
- Trump wants to turn the clock on daylight saving time
- Democrats sue to block Georgia rules that they warn will block finalization of election results
Ranking
- Don't let hackers fool you with a 'scam
- Oyster shell recycling program expands from New Orleans to Baton Rouge
- Jenna Ortega addresses rumor she was in a 'serious relationship' with Johnny Depp
- Man accused of starting destructive California wildfire by throwing firework out car window
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- Ben Affleck's Rep Addresses Kick Kennedy Dating Rumors Amid Jennifer Lopez Divorce
- 2 small planes crash in Nebraska less than half an hour apart and kill at least 1 person
- America's Got Talent Alum Grace VanderWaal Is All Grown Up in Rare Life Update
Recommendation
Trump issues order to ban transgender troops from serving openly in the military
Bradley Whitford criticizes Cheryl Hines for being 'silent' as RFK Jr. backs Donald Trump
Nationals' Dylan Crews makes MLB debut on LSU teammate Paul Skenes' heels
Second Romanian gymnast continuing to fight for bronze medal in Olympic floor final
Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
Green Bay Packers trade for Malik Willis, a backup QB with the Tennessee Titans
Tulsi Gabbard, who ran for 2020 Democratic nomination, endorses Trump against former foe Harris
'Yellowstone' First Look Week: Kayce and Monica Dutton survive into Season 5 second half